The lack of accessible information on the topic of safe parasite protection for dogs with the MDR1 gene (Multidrug Resistance gene) left me so frustrated that I decided to write my own article. So here’s the culmination of my research: information gathered from laboratory case studies, veterinarians, and Collie owners, breeders, and exhibitors. It was somehow both boring and interesting work, but it yielded helpful information.

I have an Aussie mix, plus three Rough Collies who have 1 copy of the MDR1 gene (carriers/mildly affected), so I have a vested interest in everything I’ve researched. I’ll list products I’ve looked into – several of which I’ve personally tried – along with whether they’re generally considered safe to use or should be used with caution. Technically, they’re all supposed to be safe, but some products are undoubtedly better and more consumer-trusted than others. (Follow this link for official problem drugs.)

If you’re hoping for a quick, easy skim and just want to know which pest protections are rated safest and best, I’ll give those first under each category. In fact, in full expectation most people will skim, I repeat myself a lot. Sincere apologies to those who read this article start to finish… But hey, repetition is the key to retention, right?

This is not an exhaustive listing of every product out there, but it will provide tools to identify which meds are related to each other or essentially the same as major brands. It’s all based off active ingredients. For instance, Heartgard’s main ingredient is Ivermectin, so any product containing Ivermectin falls under the same category. If you want to know about a specific product, read the active ingredients on the front of the box and compare to one of the products listed in this article. Or check the 100+ comments below this post!

For those who want more in-depth information, I’ve created embedded links throughout for further reading. (Some of the links lead to peer-reviewed scientific articles, so have fun with those if you want the bare, dusty facts.)

Disclaimer: even parasite protection products officially labeled safe – for an MDR1 dog or any dog – should really be designated “safe-ish.” But parasite preventives are chemical compounds – some of which are used in pesticides – and thus have more potential to cause a reaction than just, well, water. Any dog can be sensitive to a certain substance and should always be monitored for reactions after a new product has been administered. However, Collies and associated breeds, with or without an MDR1 status (officially the AbCb1 gene), simply have a reputation for being generally sensitive and prone to side effects from parasite preventives.

I’ll also discuss organic topicals I’ve found somewhat effective as repellents. Unfortunately I have not learned of any natural pest control products as effective as chemical-based ones. This article from Your Dog Advisor gives natural prevention options and explains how to mix your own parasite preventives using essential oils. However, dogs can also be sensitive to essential oils – like my friend who is allergic to lavender – so “natural” doesn’t automatically mean “best” for your dog either. You should still keep an eye on your pet when introducing new organic products. 

Ivermectin Poisoning from Parasite Prevention Drugs in Dogs

IVERMECTIN TOXICITY
This toxic reaction occurs especially in dogs that are genetically hypersensitive to ivermectin, an anti-parasite medication most commonly used for heartworm prevention, or to treat ear and hair mites, which can lead to mange. Ivermectin prevents or kills parasites by causing neurological damage to the parasite, resulting in paralysis and death for the parasite. But dogs genetically sensitive to the medication have an anomaly that allows the ivermectin to pass the dog’s blood-brain barrier and into its central nervous system, which can be lethal for the animal.
[slider title=”About Ivermectin “]Overview

• Parasitic diseases are common in animals. Parasites can affect the skin, ears, stomach and intestines, and the internal organs including the heart, lungs and liver. Several drugs have been developed to kill or prevent parasites such as fleas, ticks, mites and worms. Ivermectin and related drugs are among the most effective of these.
• Ivermectin is a parasite control drug. Ivermectin causes neurologic damage to the parasite, resulting in paralysis and death.
• Ivermectin has been used to prevent parasite infections, as with heartworm prevention, and to treat infections, as with ear mites.

Ivermectin as a Heartworm Preventive Medication in Dogs
Ivermectin is approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to prevent heartworm infections in dogs. Products containing Ivermectin are normally administered monthly for heartworm prevention and include medications such as Heartgard®, Iverhart®, Tri-Heart® and many other generic ivermectin-based heartworm preventive medications.

When used as a heartworm preventive medicine, ivermectin is used at much lower dosages than when used for other purposes. When used at the lower heartworm prevention dosages, ivermectin has a much lower potential for side effects than when used at higher dosages and this is the reason that ivermectin is approved for use as a heartworm preventive medication but must be used off-label (in a fashion not approved by the FDA) for many other purposes.

Read more at Suite101: Ivermectin for Dogs: Usages, Safety and Side Effects of Ivermectin in Dogs

Brand Names and Other Names

• This drug is registered for use in animals only.
• Human formulations: None
• Veterinary formulations: Ivomec® (Merial), Zimectrin® (Farnam), Eqvalan® (Merial), Heartgard® (Merial), Iverhart® (Virbac) and various generic preparations

Uses of Ivermectin

• Ivermectin is used to control skin parasites, gastrointestinal parasites and parasites within the bloodstream.
• Ivermectin prevents development of heartworm disease in dogs and cats.
• Ivermectin can be used in an extra-label manner to kill microfilaria (microscopic offspring) in heartworm infected dogs.
• Ivermectin is not effective against tapeworms and liver flukes.

How Ivermectin Is Supplied

• Ivermectin is available in 10 mg/ml and 2.7 mg/ml injectable form; 0.153 percent and 1.87 percent paste form; 10 mg/ml liquid oral form and 68 mcg, 136 mcg and 272 mcg tablets.
• Heartgard Plus® and Iverhart® are available in various concentrations of ivermectin combined with pyrantel pamoate.

Dosing Information

• Medication should never be administered without first consulting your veterinarian. The dose for ivermectin varies from species to species and also depends on the intent of treatment. General dosing guidelines follow.
• For dogs: Dose is 0.0015 to 0.003 mg per pound (0.003 to 0.006 mg/kg) once a month for heartworm prevention; 0.15 mg per pound (0.3 mg/kg) once, then repeat in 14 days for skin parasites; and 0.1 mg per pound (0.2 mg/kg) once for gastrointestinal parasites.
• For cats: Dose is 0.012 mg per pound (0.024 mg/kg) once monthly for heartworm prevention.
• The duration of administration depends on the condition being treated, response to the medication and the development of any adverse effects. Be certain to complete the prescription unless specifically directed by your veterinarian. Even if your pet feels better, the entire treatment plan should be completed to prevent relapse or prevent the development of resistance.

[/slider]

While the sensitivity to this type of medication is not always guaranteed, the following breeds are most likely to be affected (although not every “sensitive” animal in the breed is affected):

• Old English Sheepdog
• English Sheepdog
• Shetland Sheepdog (Sheltie)
• Australian Shepherd
• German Shepherd
• Long-haired Whippet
• Silken Windhound
• Skye Terrier
• Collie

Washington State University Veterinary School developed a DNA test for a mutant gene which produces adverse reaction to ivermectin and other medications in some dogs. They have discovered that 75% of Collies, 25% of Border Collies, 8% of Old English Sheep dogs, mixed dogs of these breeds, plus other breeds have this mutant gene.

It is also seen in mixed-breed dogs, older dogs that have experienced a blow to the head, puppies, dogs that have overdosed on similar types of drugs, or other central nervous system diseases that affects the blood-brain barrier. Treating dogs that are susceptible to ivermectin toxicity with parasitic medication should be only be done under a veterinarian’s supervision and with great caution.

For breeds predisposed to the disease, an autosomal recessive trait (MDR-1) gene has been identified that causes a defect in the p-glycoprotein multidrug transporter to the blood brain barrier. This allows the ivermectin to pass into the brain at low dosages thus causing toxicity. This trait may also cause toxicity from other related drugs and should also be avoided or used in lower doses in susceptible breeds.

Toxicity can occur in cats, although it is uncommon.

SYMPTOMS
Symptoms for the dog may be acute or mild. Acute signs will become apparent within 4 to 12 hours of the drug’s administration. In mild cases, symptoms will occur between 48 to 96 hours after your dog has been treated. Such symptoms include:

• Lethargy
• Depression
• Drooling
• Vomiting
• Dilation of the pupil
• Loss of appetite (anorexia)
• Difficulty controlling voluntary movement
• Disorientation
• Tremors/Seizures
• Inability to stand
• Blindness
• Slow heartbeat
• Respiratory distress
• Coma

TREATMENT
Unfortunately, ivermectin toxicity cannot be reversed. Therefore, it is best to make your pet comfortable and treat the symptoms to the best of your ability. If exposure has occurred within the past four to six hours, induce vomiting and/or administer activated charcoal for the purposes of minimizing absorption. Be on the lookout for signs of secondary complications.

Some or all of the following measures may also be recommended by your veterinarian:

• Intravenous fluid therapy
• Keeping electrolytes in balance
• Intravenous nutritional support
• Turn the dog over frequently
• Appropriate bedding
• Physical therapy
• Ocular lubricants
• Ventilator in case of respiratory distress
• Heat support if body temperature is low
• Fans if body temperature is high
• If your dog can not stand up, urinary catheters may be needed
• Medication for seizures if appropriate

Much will depend on the severity of the dog’s reaction, along with its initial overall health. It may take several weeks of dedicated care before the dog fully recovers.

PREVENTION
There is a test available to check sensitivity to ivermectin. If your dog is one of the breeds that is prone to ivermectin toxicity, you might consider testing for it. If you decide not to have the testing done, be cautious about using ivermectin to prevent heartworm disease or for the treatment of mites.

In dogs with MDR 1 gene mutation, the following drugs should be avoided or used with caution:

• Ivermectin
• Selamectin
• Milbemycin
• Moxidectin
• Loperamide
• Acepromazine
• Butorphanol
• Vincristine
• Vinblastine
• Doxorubicin

WHY TELL YOU ALL THIS?
I include all this scary stuff so you know what can go wrong when using ivermectin on your own to treat your pets. It’s the same ingredient used in the popular heartworm meds you can buy for cats and dogs, but I know someone whose dog died when she administered Zimecterin Gold, a horse wormer, to her dogs. I don’t know the particulars in her case — what breed her dog was, how much she dosed, etc. I offer this info so you know what can go wrong and are as informed as possible before going this route. I assume no responsibility. Zimecterin Gold contains ivermectin and praziquantel. The praziquantel kills tapeworms. I have used this product for several years on my cats and dogs with no ill effects (knock on wood). My dogs are mutts. But be aware of the hazards if you have any of the breeds mentioned above. Having several cats and dogs, this is a more affordable alternative for me. There are several generic versions of heartworm preventative on the market. I used to order them from PetShed out of Australia. That worked fine, too. However, I have a number of cats and dogs and even the generic version became quite expensive.

Animals at highest risk are very young dogs, multi-drug sensitive breeds, dogs that may be exposed to ivermectin-containing products for large animals and/or the feces of large animals (horses, cows, pigs) treated with ivermectin.

Zemecterin Gold comes in an oversized syringe with a dosage appropriate for horses. The plunger on the syringe is marked at 50 lb intervals. This is how I determine the appropriate dosage. One syringe treats approximately 1300 pounds and costs about $15.

You can also buy the cattle version of just plain 1% ivomec (without the praziquantel), but it requires a larger dosage ivermectin (1/10 of 1 cc per 10 pounds) and it tastes really nasty. So you need to mix it in something like orange juice or yogurt.

Note: Cats can experience ivermectin toxicity. A small percentage of cats (less than dogs) have a sensitivity  to it and will react adversely to Ivermectin. It’s very easy to overdose them. Safe dewormers for cats are not that much more expensive than ivermectin. Praziquantel and pyrantel pamoate are 2 that can be used with less risk and the most common ones you’ll find sold for cats.

From a reader: I use Ivermectin Horse for basic worms in all our adult dogs and pups over 8 wks (Golden retrievers)by mixing with corn oil 6-1 ratio and dosing at 1ml/15#.